Page 4 of 17
Posted: Tue Nov 02, 2010 9:07 pm
by darren
I've just watched two of the reconstructions - Tunnel of Fear and Dragonsfield.
I always liked the sound of these from the synopsis and the recons proved very enjoyable in bringing alive the story. Great job
I've completed disc 5 and didn't notice any sound issues - not to say they aren't there but my enjoyment of the episodes was in no way impaired.
Posted: Tue Nov 02, 2010 10:33 pm
by rdc180368
Cybernowt wrote:People were saying that they werent going to pre-order series 5, due to the errors with series 4. I wish I'd listened.
To be honest, I've not got around to watching any of the eps yet, I just put a disc in to look through the extras. I have though been waiting for this box set to come out [for a long time] to watch the eps in their supposed absolute best. Otherwise I could have just rewatched my old vhs'.
If this problem is going to be addressed, it would be nice to know. Otherwise I'm looking into sending it back asap, and I wont be pre-ordering series 6. The set was too much money to keep if its duff. I generally always wait to buy box sets. I never buy dvds when they first come out. I have patience and always wait for a few months to get them cheaper. But when I really fancy watching something, I'll splash out a bit more and buy is as soon as it appears. This [and series 4] was the only time I've done this in a couple of years at least. Which only adds to my annoyance.
Sorry if I appear overly snippy with this post. I know its not the end of the world by a long way, but I really do feel like I've been done.
I returned Series 4 because it clearly wasn't right and I still felt there were one or two outstanding issues (at least on the ones I had) that weren't addressed by the replacement discs. I just decided to cut my losses.
I hoped Series 5 would be okay... I wasn't especially pessimistic before it arrived - I don't think you can go through life expecting the worst in absolutely everything - and it's been disappointing to find problems with these too. Again, I've just decided to draw a line under it and send them back for a refund.
Hopefully things will be okay with Series 6. The restored screen shots look terrific and hopefully everything else will be as expected too.
Posted: Wed Nov 03, 2010 12:18 am
by Alan
Darren wrote:I've just watched two of the reconstructions - Tunnel of Fear and Dragonsfield.
I always liked the sound of these from the synopsis and the recons proved very enjoyable in bringing alive the story. Great job.
Thanks, Darren. These ones are Alys' babies really. She wrote the narration scripts and did the bulk of the video editing. I just put the images together, recorded and edited the audio and made tea and mopped her brow! She did a great job, I think!
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 2:08 am
by dissolute
Hmmm, I might cancel my Amazon order. Can anyone verify these problems are definite?
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 8:20 am
by Alan
Yes, they are definite.
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 9:38 am
by dissolute
Shame.
I was so looking forward to the extras and your reconstructions.
Oh well, that'll give me more time to rework season 3 - and I've decided to bite the bullet and redo
every single mugshot on the site - making then 250 pixels square instead of 150 square. I'll need an additional 25MB of disk space but I have about 200MB free on my host so there's no problem there.
I might even throw in super-size enlargements for the major guest stars, the prinicipals and I'll definitely redo and standardise the "feature images" illustrating the episodes. Some of those Emma Peel pictures are downright shoddy and need to go!
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 2:25 pm
by MRotten
Are the sound problems limited to 2 episodes, or are there more episodes with audio flaws?
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 3:17 pm
by darren
Personally speaking, if the audio fault is on every episode then I wouldn't have noticed them at all unless someone had pointed it out.
It's probably more obvious to those used to the A&E releases.
If replacements weren't offered then personally it wouldn't bother me in the slightest.
The "corrected" audio examples done by a guy on the Roobarbs Forum sounded odd to me but that's apparently how Steed and Emma are supposed to sound
. I'll possibly stick with the set as it is as as I said I never noticed the issue.
I watched Who's Who??? and Return of the Cybernauts last night (both look stunning) and really enjoyed them - this audio issue didn't infringe on my enjoyment at all.
faults
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 4:06 pm
by servalan66
well I beg to differ, and your hearing cannot be that good, the sound issues are very noticable, as no doubt optimum will admit. whether they replace them all is another matter. and I am not used to the american ones, only ever had the uk videos and dvd's.
Re: faults
Posted: Thu Nov 04, 2010 4:46 pm
by darren
servalan66 wrote:well I beg to differ, and your hearing cannot be that good, the sound issues are very noticable, as no doubt optimum will admit. whether they replace them all is another matter. and I am not used to the american ones, only ever had the uk videos and dvd's.
As I said on Roobards, my hearing is fine thank you.
Is it so impossible for you to understand that I do not have a major issue with this.
Edited as it's not meant to come over as aggressive.