Page 4 of 10

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 12:57 am
by Artanis
I agree, Philippa! I think it's one of Honor's best performances in the show and being in b&w makes the episode feel even more creepy.
moorlock2003 wrote:"Who's Who" doesn't bore me; it's just disconcerting seeing Macnee and Rigg acting deviously. The episode was a bit too far-fetched. From Season 5, I like "The Correct Way To Kill" with Michael Gough, great in "The Cybernauts" as well. I can see how new viewers, if they were first exposed to the series via the colour Emmas, might be turned off to the show. Some of them were on the silly side.
The color seasons with Emma and Tara were my introduction to the show. One of things I liked was the mixture of serious and silly episodes, like "The Joker" and "Epic." If I watched the Cathy Gale episodes first, I wonder whether or not I would have became a fan of the series.

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 6:09 am
by Timeless A-Peel
Whiskers wrote:
DiVicenzo wrote:
Strange Young Man wrote: She would've been had the script required it. You're right- that part is a poorly written excuse to allow her to get captured by the helicopter. I do like the episode, though, depite one or two daft moments.

Yes, I love 'Murdersville' too - I don't care about daft moments either! I like that scene in the fields with the helicopter. Diana looks wunderbar!
The chopper scene has never bothered me. I assumed, as she would have, that the rest of the villagers are following on foot. So she would have to keep moving.
Whenever Steed and co. do something terribly stupid for the sake of TV show logic (and the plot), I like to remind myself that all of these people have suffered quite a few blows to the head. :wink:

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 8:02 am
by Frankymole
Whiskers wrote: The chopper scene has never bothered me. I assumed, as she would have, that the rest of the villagers are following on foot. So she would have to keep moving.
In that case she should've climbed a tree and hid, not left the forest :)

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 9:59 am
by Dandy Forsdyke
Strange Young Man wrote:
She would've been had the script required it. You're right- that part is a poorly written excuse to allow her to get captured by the helicopter. I do like the episode, though, depite one or two daft moments.
What was the episode where Tara made her escape and climbed down a Well? Brings the phrase sitting duck to mind...

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 10:08 am
by DiVicenzo
Frankymole wrote:
Whiskers wrote: The chopper scene has never bothered me. I assumed, as she would have, that the rest of the villagers are following on foot. So she would have to keep moving.
In that case she should've climbed a tree and hid, not left the forest :)

Then we wouldn't have those fabulous shots of her looking behind her as she is being chased! It would have been less dramatic for the viewer.

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 3:54 pm
by darren
Dandy Forsdyke wrote:
Strange Young Man wrote:
She would've been had the script required it. You're right- that part is a poorly written excuse to allow her to get captured by the helicopter. I do like the episode, though, depite one or two daft moments.
What was the episode where Tara made her escape and climbed down a Well? Brings the phrase sitting duck to mind...
Noon Doomsday. She didn't escape down a well, she went to investigate a dead body. Of course the murderer appeared at the top when she reached the bottom but she knocked him out with the well handle - climbed back to the top as he came around and then had a fight - she won. She had great stamina.:)

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 5:35 pm
by moorlock2003
Darren wrote:
Dandy Forsdyke wrote:
Strange Young Man wrote:
She would've been had the script required it. You're right- that part is a poorly written excuse to allow her to get captured by the helicopter. I do like the episode, though, depite one or two daft moments.
What was the episode where Tara made her escape and climbed down a Well? Brings the phrase sitting duck to mind...
Noon Doomsday. She didn't escape down a well, she went to investigate a dead body. Of course the murderer appeared at the top when she reached the bottom but she knocked him out with the well handle - climbed back to the top as he came around and then had a fight - she won. She had great stamina.:)
She sure did. Tara was one tough cookie in her fights.

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 10:18 pm
by mousemeat
moorlock2003 wrote:
Darren wrote:
Dandy Forsdyke wrote: What was the episode where Tara made her escape and climbed down a Well? Brings the phrase sitting duck to mind...
Noon Doomsday. She didn't escape down a well, she went to investigate a dead body. Of course the murderer appeared at the top when she reached the bottom but she knocked him out with the well handle - climbed back to the top as he came around and then had a fight - she won. She had great stamina.:)
She sure did. Tara was one tough cookie in her fights.
would that be with or without that BRICK in her purse ?

(LOL)

actually, TARA improved her fighting skills, greatly..as the series wound down..

Re: good points

Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 11:14 pm
by moorlock2003
mousemeat wrote:
moorlock2003 wrote:
Darren wrote: Noon Doomsday. She didn't escape down a well, she went to investigate a dead body. Of course the murderer appeared at the top when she reached the bottom but she knocked him out with the well handle - climbed back to the top as he came around and then had a fight - she won. She had great stamina.:)
She sure did. Tara was one tough cookie in her fights.
would that be with or without that BRICK in her purse ?

(LOL)

actually, TARA improved her fighting skills, greatly..as the series wound down..
That "brick in the purse" bit in "The Forget-Me-Knot" was there for the sake of amusement, no other reason. There was hardly time for Tara to try out her fighting skills. This was her introductory episode and it wasn't meant as a full-scale showing of what she was capable of doing.

Posted: Sat Nov 22, 2008 12:19 am
by Dandy Forsdyke
The brick-in-the-handbag was a mistake. They should have given her a decent scrap. Diana was doing it all in that episode.